Good case on age discrimination defense using evidence of hiring of other older employees
October 31, 2003Shannon P. Duffy writes in The Legal Intelligencer
“‘Subsequent Good Act’ by Employer Admissible
Company sued for age discrimination can show it hired older worker.”
“In an age discrimination suit, the defendant company may present evidence that it hired another older worker more than a year after the plaintiff was fired because such evidence is relevant to the issue of the employer’s alleged discriminatory intent, the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled.”
“In Ansell v. Green Acres Contracting Co., a unanimous three-judge panel found that trial judges have the discretion under Federal Rule of Evidence 404(b) to allow such evidence of a “subsequent good act.”
The article contains a good, fairly detailed summary of the arguments opposing admissibility of such evidence raised by the plaintiff — and rejected by the court.
This case may not be groundbreaking, but it is nonetheless noteworthy for highlighting a potentially useful line of defense.
Rather than fighting attempts by a plaintiff to introduce evidence of terminations of other employees in a protected class, if an employer has good counter-evidence of favorable treatment, using such evidence in rebuttal may be quite potent.
Conceivably it would paint a very persuasive defense picture for a jury in an age case to be shown a parade of gray-haired employees testifying to how the people who allegedly committed age discrimination hired them, promoted them, gave them good evaluations and raises, etc.
Related Posts
Preview of arguments in reverse-discrimination age case at Supreme Court
Case emphasizes discrimination charge relationship to lawsuit allegations; also key points for retaliation cases
Eighth Circuit indicates its application of Desert Palace v. Costa; says 2 months too long for inference of retaliation
Seventh Circuit deals with ADA and FMLA in case of…
Seventh Circuit case illustrates several useful defenses to discrimination claims
No Comments »
No comments yet.
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
If you want to leave a feedback to this post or to some other user´s comment, simply fill out the form below.